CO129-189 - Governor Hennessy - 1880 [7-9] — Page 540

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

of Superintendents General and manager to the Garden Committee, and it is a matter of considerable regret to me that I should not have been more fortunate than The Hardy R.C. in my relations with Mr. Ford.

4. The inconsistency of holding me responsible for the proper laying out of public moneys while I was excluded from the supervision of Garden works was brought to the notice of Sir Arthur Kennedy. His Excellency, upon looking into matters, discovered that the creation of a separate Department for the Gardens in January 1872 had also surprised him.

He was surprised to find that notwithstanding Macdonnell's decisive minute of the 9th of January 1872, relieving the Public Works Department from charge of Garden matters, the Government had found itself compelled to revert to that Department for the proper superintendence of the Garden work of 1872-3, and consequently Sir Arthur Kennedy had the less hesitation in cancelling a minute which practical experience had proved to be unsatisfactory.

In speaking of his predecessor's minute constituting the Gardens a separate Department, Sir Arthur Kennedy expressed his conviction that the arrangements under that minute could not have been intended to be permanent and that they had their origin in special causes.

Page 541

Edit History

2026-05-21 23:40:28 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
of Superintendents General and manager to the Garden Committee, and it is a matter of considerable regret to me that I should not have been more fortunate than The Hardy R.C. in my relations with Mr. Ford. 4. The inconsistency of holding me responsible for the proper laying out of public moneys while I was excluded from the supervision of Garden works was brought to the notice of Sir Arthur Kennedy. His Excellency, upon looking into matters, discovered that the creation of a separate Department for the Gardens in January 1872 had also surprised him. He was surprised to find that notwithstanding Macdonnell's decisive minute of the 9th of January 1872, relieving the Public Works Department from charge of Garden matters, the Government had found itself compelled to revert to that Department for the proper superintendence of the Garden work of 1872-3, and consequently Sir Arthur Kennedy had the less hesitation in cancelling a minute which practical experience had proved to be unsatisfactory. In speaking of his predecessor's minute constituting the Gardens a separate Department, Sir Arthur Kennedy expressed his conviction that the arrangements under that minute could not have been intended to be permanent and that they had their origin in special causes. Page 541
Baseline (Original)
of Sucoups General and manager to the Garden Committee, and it of considerable re- load a matter zgret to me that I should not have been any Explaine relations with more fortunate tham The Hardy R.C. in Mr forb. my me 4. The inconsistency of holding responsible for the proper laying out of public moneys while I wast Garden works was excluded from their supervision, having been brought by to the notice of Sir Arthur i= Kennedy, His Excellency upon looking into matters, discovered that the creation of Department for M. Ford of Famiary 1872. -Government Arthur Kennedy 537 also surprised. Q to find that notwithstanding Macdonnell's decisive minute of the the 9th of January 18772, relieving the Public Works Department from charge of Garden matters, the Govern- :ment had found itself compelled to revent to that Department for the pro. - per superintendence of the Farden work of 1872 - 3, and conse consequently - Sir Arthur Kennedy had the less Cancelling hesitation in cance A minutes. which practical experience hat provid insperation. In Q peroking his predecessors minute constituting the Gardens 7. on the geh seven months after that officer's arrival in the Colang had not originated with Your Lordship, for that it had even been brought to Your Lordship's Curwledge Sir separates Department Sir Arthur Ken- * -nedy expressed his conviction that the arra cals unde under that minutes. arrangements could peech have been intended to be permanent and that they di their origin to special causes which Arthur. had E }Page 541
2026-05-21 23:40:28 · Baseline
View content

of Sucoups General and manager to the Garden Committee, and it of considerable re-

load a

matter

zgret to me that I should not have

been

any

Explaine relations with

more fortunate tham The Hardy R.C. in

Mr forb.

my

me

4. The inconsistency of holding responsible for the proper laying out of public moneys while I wast

Garden works

was excluded from

their

supervision, having been brought by to the notice of Sir Arthur i= Kennedy, His Excellency upon looking into matters, discovered that the creation of Department for M. Ford

of Famiary 1872.

-Government

Arthur Kennedy

537

also surprised.

Q

to find that notwithstanding Macdonnell's decisive minute of the

the

9th of January 18772, relieving the Public Works Department from charge of Garden matters, the Govern- :ment had found itself compelled to revent to that Department for

the

pro.

- per superintendence of the Farden

work of 1872 - 3, and conse

consequently

-

Sir Arthur Kennedy had the less

Cancelling

hesitation in cance

A minutes.

which practical experience hat provid insperation.

In

Q

peroking his predecessors

minute constituting the Gardens

7.

on

the geh

seven months after

that officer's arrival in the Colang had

not originated with Your Lordship,

for that it had even

been brought

to Your Lordship's Curwledge

Sir

separates Department Sir Arthur Ken-

*

-nedy expressed his conviction that

the arra

cals unde

under that minutes.

arrangements

could

peech

have been intended to

be permanent and that they

di

their origin to special causes which

Arthur.

had

E

}Page 541

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.